NOTICE: This site has been archived. All content is read-only and registration is disabled.

A new site is being built and the Basic Action Games Discord server is an active hub for discussion and games.

-Admin

non-scaling attack weak spot

Your house rules, and add-ons
Post Reply
User avatar
dugfromthearth
Costumed Crimefighter
Costumed Crimefighter
Posts: 165
Joined: Mon Aug 16, 2010 11:00 pm

non-scaling attack weak spot

Post by dugfromthearth »

last night we faced the master villain who had attack weak spot and x6 damage.

For 2 pts, attack weak spot doubles the damage if you hit by 20.
Since this is a multiplication not an addition, it gets better the more powerful you already are - which seem to me the opposite of its intent.

I would think attack weak spot would be for low powered characters to occasionally boost their damage.

I suggest:

Attack Weak Spot 1+
At level 1 your attacks do +x2 DM when you hit by +10 points. Each additional level adds +x2 DM when you hit by an additional +10 points. So at level 3 if you hit by +10 you do +x1 DM, if you hit by +20 you do +x2 DM, if you hit by +30 you do +x3 DM

note that this removes the ability to spend a hero point to use your to hit roll for damage, but that can be left in
User avatar
Michael
Costumed Crimefighter
Costumed Crimefighter
Posts: 134
Joined: Sat Jul 24, 2010 11:00 pm

Post by Michael »

Good point.

Attack Weak Point is a problem since in the current rules it is too effective when used by people with high damage multipliers, when it is supposed to be used mostly by people with X2 or X3 multipliers.

A simpler approach might be to have attack weak point increase the damage multiplier by 3 if you hit by 20+.
A X1 DMG attack becomes X4,
A X2 DMG attack becomes X5,
and a X6 DMG attack becomes X9 instead of X12.
User avatar
WaylanderPK
Costumed Crimefighter
Costumed Crimefighter
Posts: 189
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2011 11:00 pm

Post by WaylanderPK »

I like that solution Michael.
I've also been toying with limiting Attack Weak Point to only being used with intense trained powers and normal weapons, but you could still end up with a sniper doing x7 to Hit, x5 Damage attack weak point. Which is still pretty effective.

My feeling is if you want you special attack to do more damage you should just buy "extra effect if hit by +20", which would give you an additional x2DM on a good hit.

Its obvious that attack weak point is pretty powerful by the number of time pc's like to power stunt it ;)
Post Reply