BeardedDork wrote:I would like to voice my opinion that I would prefer to have the game run here.
BASH is intended to be run as a completely open system.
...
The game is not intended to have the "Tell me what you rolled, and I'll tell you whether or not you succeeded" attitude common to other games.
The player should always know the difficulty of their actions. They need to know how much they have succeeded or failed by on any given action so they can determine how and when to spend their Hero points and Hero dice.
My two cents.
I agree with all of the above. It was a *change* for me to do alot of this when starting to Narrate BASH! But that's how the system intends it.
I'd also note that running the game here on the BASH! forums would be a good "promotion" for BASH! overall, if people want to see some Actual Play.
Lastly - yeah, I think you're figuring out using the auto-die rolling system someone helped build into the forum. I'd forgotten about it! It seemed to work great when I tested it, after learning of it.
I see no reason you (as Narrator) couldn't ask for a die roll, and at the same time give the Target Number (or the contested Target Number) roll. Then also note if YOU want to spend any Setback Points to up YOUR rolls, etc...
Then allow players to respond using that die-roll system, along with adding any of their own Hero Points or Dice if they want to change the results with them.
just my thoughts
-kev-